That evolution Today, libraries serve many purposes, providing Internet access, meeting spaces, and even community pantries. But the heart of their mission remains the same: lending.
What has chang is how that core mission is accomplish. Like copyright law itself, library lending has evolv as new systems and technologies have creat new ways to meet patron nes. For the past decade, digital lending—a modern, more efficient version of lending that is us by libraries across the country. Controll digital lending allows libraries to lend books via the internet subject to strict controls, for a limit time, to one patron at a time.
But four giant publishers claim that this service violates their copyrights and threatens their businesses.
They are wrong That evolution
Libraries have paid publishers billions of special database for the books in their print collections. CDL merely helps libraries better serve their patrons, but still lending just one book at a time. It is fundamentally the same as traditional library lending and poses no harm to authors or the publishing industry. In fact, the concrete evidence in this case shows that the Archive’s digital lending does not and will not harm the market for books.
The district court gave short shrift to
That evidence, one of many flaws in australia email list ruling. Another was that it conclud that the Internet Archive’s free public library is actually a commercial activity. According to the court, a nonprofit has a commercial purpose if it derives to arrange the suitable candidate any benefit connect to its a work – including ordinary nonprofit activities like attracting new members, receiving recognition from its community, or having a donate button its website. That definition of “commercial” runs contrary to well-establish precent. What is worse, it would apply to almost every library and public interest organization in the country. It doesn’t make sense.